| 1 | I1707 | Coddington, Benjamin Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | BENJAMIN,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,BENJAMIN | March 1838 | 175 | Middletown | 4 | before 1943 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 2 | I2169 | Coddington, Daniel Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | DANIEL,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,DANIEL | 1838 | 175 | OH | 0 | before 1943 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 3 | I2168 | Coddington, Elizabeth Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | ELIZABETH,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,ELIZABETH | 1837 | 176 | OH | 0 | before 1942 | | | | | F | YES | YES | |
| 4 | I2163 | Coddington, Elmer A. M Father: Coddington, Benjamin
Mother: Morris, Martha J. | ELMER A. M,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,ELMER A. M | May 1864 | 149 | OH | 1 | before 1969 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 5 | I2166 | Coddington, Harry B. Father: Coddington, Benjamin
Mother: Morris, Martha J. | HARRY B.,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,HARRY B. | February 1870 | 143 | OH | 0 | before 1975 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 6 | I2164 | Coddington, Harry E. Father: Coddington, Elmer A. M
| HARRY E.,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,HARRY E. | April 1887 | 126 | OH | 0 | before 1992 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 7 | I2167 | Coddington, James Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | JAMES,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,JAMES | 1833 | 180 | OH | 0 | before 1938 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 8 | I2172 | Coddington, John Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | JOHN,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,JOHN | 1849 | 164 | OH | 0 | before 1954 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 9 | I2165 | Coddington, Milton C. Father: Coddington, Benjamin
Mother: Morris, Martha J. | MILTON C.,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,MILTON C. | 1867 | 146 | OH | 0 | before 1972 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 10 | I906 | Coddington, Nell E. Father: Coddington, Benjamin
Mother: Morris, Martha J. | NELL E.,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,NELL E. | 7 October 1879 | 133 | Middletown | 0 | 15 March 1944 | 69 | 64 | Columbus | | F | YES | Y100 | |
| 11 | I2161 | Coddington, Robert | ROBERT,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,ROBERT | 1792 | 221 | MD | 7 | before 1897 | | | | | M | YES | YES | R |
| 12 | I2171 | Coddington, Robert Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | ROBERT,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,ROBERT | 1844 | 169 | OH | 0 | before 1949 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |
| 13 | I2170 | Coddington, William Father: Coddington, Robert
Mother: Isabella, (unknown) | WILLIAM,CODDINGTON | CODDINGTON,WILLIAM | 1842 | 171 | OH | 0 | before 1947 | | | | | M | YES | YES | |